The Greatest Super Bowl Upsets of All Time
The Super Bowl is the biggest stage in American sports — and while dynasties often dominate, some of the most unforgettable moments in NFL history have come when the underdogs pulled off the impossible. These shocking victories remind fans why football is unpredictable, thrilling, and legendary. Here’s a look back at the greatest Super Bowl upsets of all time.
Super Bowl III (1969): Jets Shock the Colts
Before the AFL and NFL officially merged, many doubted that the AFL could compete. That all changed when Joe Namath and the New York Jets upset the heavily favored Baltimore Colts.
-
Namath famously guaranteed victory before the game.
-
The Jets won 16–7, proving the AFL’s legitimacy.
-
This upset changed pro football forever, cementing the Super Bowl as must-see TV.
Super Bowl XXXII (1998): Broncos Beat the Packers
The defending champion Green Bay Packers, led by Brett Favre, were double-digit favorites. But John Elway and the Denver Broncos had other plans.
-
Running back Terrell Davis powered the Broncos with 157 yards and three touchdowns.
-
Elway’s iconic “helicopter run” symbolized Denver’s determination.
-
Final score: Broncos 31, Packers 24 — Elway’s first Super Bowl win.
Super Bowl XLII (2008): Giants End the Perfect Season
Perhaps the most famous upset in modern NFL history came when the New York Giants took down the undefeated New England Patriots.
-
The Patriots entered 18–0, aiming for a perfect season.
-
Eli Manning’s miraculous escape and David Tyree’s helmet catch became an instant classic.
-
The Giants’ defense shut down Tom Brady, winning 17–14.
Super Bowl XLVII (2012): Giants Do It Again
Four years later, the Giants once again spoiled the Patriots’ championship hopes.
-
Eli Manning delivered clutch throws in the fourth quarter.
-
Wide receiver Mario Manningham’s sideline catch set up the game-winning drive.
-
Giants 21, Patriots 17 — proving lightning can strike twice.
Super Bowl XXXVI (2002): Patriots Stun the Rams
Before Tom Brady was a legend, he was a second-year quarterback leading the underdog Patriots against the powerhouse St. Louis Rams, known as “The Greatest Show on Turf.”
-
The Rams were 14-point favorites with stars like Kurt Warner and Marshall Faulk.
-
Brady’s poise set up Adam Vinatieri’s game-winning field goal.
-
Patriots 20, Rams 17 — the start of a dynasty.
Why Super Bowl Upsets Captivate Fans
Super Bowl upsets embody what makes football magical: no matter the odds, any team can rise to the occasion. These games are remembered not just for the scores, but for the iconic plays and larger-than-life moments that define NFL history.
Relive NFL History with Vintage Gear
At Gametime Vintage, we celebrate these unforgettable games with authentic vintage NFL apparel. Whether you’re a fan of the Giants, Patriots, Broncos, or Jets, our collection of throwback NFL sweatshirts, jackets, and tees lets you relive the moments that made football history.
👉 Shop Vintage NFL Gear Now at GametimeVintage.com
Final Thoughts
From Joe Namath’s guarantee to the Giants’ helmet catch, the biggest Super Bowl upsets remind us why the game is more than just a sport — it’s history in the making. These underdog triumphs will live on forever in the hearts of football fans.
